The short answer
The right amount of homeowners insurance starts with one number: the replacement cost of your house, meaning what a builder would charge today to reconstruct it on the same lot with similar materials. Your dwelling limit should equal that number. Almost every other limit on the policy is set as a percentage of it.
Replacement cost is not the price you paid, your mortgage balance, your tax assessment, or the figure on a real estate website. All of those include land and reflect what buyers will pay. A fire does not destroy the land, and a builder's invoice does not depend on the housing market. The calculator above works from square footage and construction cost, which is how an insurer's own estimating software works.
How the calculator works
- Replacement cost = finished square footage × rebuild cost per square foot, increased by 15% for a finished basement and 5% for a pool.
- Dwelling (Coverage A) is set equal to replacement cost.
- Other structures (Coverage B) is 10% of the dwelling limit, or the value you enter for detached structures.
- Personal property (Coverage C) is the value you enter, or 50% of the dwelling limit if you leave it blank.
- Loss of use (Coverage D) is 20% of the dwelling limit.
- Liability (Coverage E) is the limit you choose, and medical payments (Coverage F) is shown at a standard $5,000.
- Rough premium = dwelling limit ÷ 1,000 × $8, the approximate national average rate.
The 80% rule check then compares the dwelling limit on your current policy with 80% of the replacement cost and shows what a partial loss would pay.
A worked example
A 2,500 square foot house in an area where comparable construction costs $150 per square foot:
| Coverage | How it is set | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| A: Dwelling | 2,500 sq ft × $150 | $375,000 |
| B: Other structures | 10% of dwelling | $37,500 |
| C: Personal property | Your estimate | $150,000 |
| D: Loss of use | 20% of dwelling | $75,000 |
| E: Personal liability | Your choice | $300,000 |
| F: Medical payments | Standard | $5,000 |
| Rough annual premium | $375,000 ÷ 1,000 × $8 | $3,000 |
If this house sits on an $80,000 lot and would sell for $400,000, its structure is "worth" $320,000 on the market but costs $375,000 to rebuild. Insuring it for market value minus land would leave a $55,000 gap.
Estimating the cost to rebuild
The rebuild cost per square foot is the most important input and the one most people guess. It varies widely by region and by the quality of the house. Basic construction in a low-cost area can be near $150 per square foot, while custom homes and high-cost metros run $300 to $400 or more. Better sources than a guess, in rough order of reliability:
- A replacement cost estimate from your insurer or agent, which you can ask to see line by line.
- A local builder's current price per square foot for a home of similar quality.
- A replacement cost appraisal, worth paying for on a custom, historic, or unusually large home.
Whatever the source, check that the description of the house is right. Estimates go wrong when they miss:
- Finished basements, attics, and additions built after the policy was written.
- Kitchen and bathroom remodels with upgraded cabinets, stone counters, or tile.
- Construction details: plaster walls, hardwood floors, a slate or tile roof, masonry exterior.
- Demolition and debris removal, which a total loss requires before rebuilding can start.
Every renovation raises your replacement cost. Tell your insurer after a remodel. If you have just finished a kitchen or bathroom project, the invoice total is a reasonable amount to add.
The six coverages on a homeowners policy
| Coverage | What it pays for | Typical limit |
|---|---|---|
| A: Dwelling | The house and attached structures such as a garage or deck | 100% of replacement cost |
| B: Other structures | Detached garage, shed, fence, guest house | 10% of A |
| C: Personal property | Furniture, clothing, electronics, and other belongings | 50% to 70% of A |
| D: Loss of use | Rent, hotel, and extra living costs while the home is repaired | 20% to 30% of A |
| E: Personal liability | Injury or property damage you are legally responsible for | $100,000 to $500,000 |
| F: Medical payments | Small medical bills for guests hurt on your property, regardless of fault | $1,000 to $5,000 |
The percentages are defaults, not rules. If you have a large detached workshop, raise Coverage B. If you own more or less than half your dwelling limit in belongings, change Coverage C. The personal property coverage calculator estimates that number room by room.
The 80% rule, and what it costs to miss it
Most homeowners policies contain a loss settlement condition, often called the 80% rule. It says that damage to the house is paid at full replacement cost only if, at the time of the loss, your dwelling limit is at least 80% of the home's replacement cost. If it is lower, the insurer pays the larger of two amounts: the actual cash value of the damage, which is replacement cost less depreciation, or a proportional share calculated as:
payout = (limit carried ÷ 80% of replacement cost) × loss − deductible
The penalty applies to partial losses, which are far more common than total ones. Take the house above, with a replacement cost of $375,000. The 80% line is $300,000. Suppose the owner bought the policy years ago and still carries $240,000, and a kitchen fire causes $40,000 of damage with a $2,500 deductible.
- Insured to at least $300,000: the policy pays $40,000 − $2,500 = $37,500.
- Insured to $240,000: the policy pays ($240,000 ÷ $300,000) × $40,000 − $2,500 = $29,500.
The owner absorbs $8,000 of a loss that was well within the policy limit. Construction costs rise most years, so a limit that met the rule when the policy was written can slip below it without any change to the house. Enter your current dwelling limit in the teal box in the calculator to see where you stand. Your policy's own loss settlement wording controls, so read that section or ask your agent.
Endorsements that protect the dwelling limit
- Extended replacement cost. Pays an extra percentage above the dwelling limit, commonly 10% to 50%, if rebuilding costs more than expected. This matters after a regional disaster, when labor and material prices spike.
- Guaranteed replacement cost. Pays whatever it takes to rebuild, regardless of the limit. Fewer insurers offer it.
- Inflation guard. Raises the dwelling limit automatically at each renewal. Check that the increase keeps pace with local construction costs.
- Ordinance or law. Pays the added cost of rebuilding to current building codes. Standard policies often include only 10% of the dwelling limit, which can fall short for an older home.
- Water backup. Covers damage from a backed-up sewer or failed sump pump, which the base policy excludes.
Liability: match it to what you could lose
Liability coverage pays if someone is injured on your property or you damage someone else's, and it pays for your legal defense. The usual advice is to carry at least as much as your net worth. Most insurers sell $100,000, $300,000, and $500,000 limits, and the higher limits add relatively little to the premium. A pool, a trampoline, a dog, or frequent guests are all reasons to choose the top limit and consider a personal umbrella policy, which typically adds $1 million of coverage above both your home and auto policies.
What a standard policy does not cover
- Flood. Excluded on every standard homeowners form. Coverage comes from the National Flood Insurance Program, up to $250,000 for the building and $100,000 for contents, or from a private flood insurer.
- Earthquake and earth movement. A separate policy or endorsement.
- Wear, neglect, and maintenance problems. A roof that fails from age is not a covered loss.
- Sewer backup, unless you add the endorsement.
- High-value items above special limits. Jewelry, firearms, and silverware have low theft caps unless scheduled.
Our comparison of home warranties and insurance explains which kinds of failures neither one pays for.
What the premium depends on
The calculator's premium figure uses a single national rate of about $8 per $1,000 of dwelling coverage, which matches a 2026 average of roughly $2,400 a year for $300,000 of dwelling coverage. Treat it as an order of magnitude. Published state averages run from about $1,000 a year in the least expensive states to more than $6,000 in the most expensive, and the factors behind your own quote include:
- Location: exposure to hurricanes, hail, tornadoes, and wildfire, and distance to a fire station.
- The age and material of the roof, and the age of the wiring, plumbing, and heating.
- Your deductible. Many policies in wind and hail states use a percentage deductible, 1% to 5% of the dwelling limit, for those perils. On a $375,000 limit, 2% is $7,500.
- Claims history, for both you and the property.
- Credit-based insurance score, in the states that allow it.
- Discounts for bundling, security and leak-detection devices, and a newer roof.
When to recalculate
Run the numbers again at every renewal, and immediately after a renovation or addition, a new roof, a major purchase, a change in how you use the home such as starting a business or renting a room, or a sharp rise in local construction costs. Compare the result with the Coverage A limit on your declarations page. If the limit is below the calculator's figure, ask your agent for a new replacement cost estimate.
Coverage is half of it; proof is the other half
A correct limit sets the most the policy can pay. What it actually pays depends on what you can document after a loss: the features and finishes of the house, the improvements you made, and what you owned. Photos of every room, invoices for renovations, and an inventory kept somewhere other than the house turn a negotiation into a list. See our guides to documenting your home for insurance claims and filing a claim step by step.
What the estimate leaves out
The calculator does not replace an insurer's replacement cost estimate or a quote. It uses one cost per square foot for the whole house, fixed adjustments for a basement and a pool, and a single national premium rate. It does not price flood, earthquake, or windstorm policies, endorsements, or discounts, and it applies the standard form of the 80% rule, which your policy may modify.
Figures last reviewed November 2026. See our calculator methodology.